open peer review 開放式同儕審查的兩個要素
1.審查人的名字列在審查意見書上
2.如果稿件出版，審查意見書可以隨著文稿的最終版在線上可以查閱
Open peer review" means that, firstly, the reviewers' names are included on the peer review reports, and secondly that, if the manuscript is published, the reports are made available online along with the final version of the manuscript. The published article will provide a link to its 'pre-publication history', which lists all the versions of the manuscript, all the signed reviews, and all responses to the reviewers since the submission of the manuscript until its publication.
參考資料來源http://www.biomedcentral.com/authors/authorfaq/medical
crowd-sourced peer review
The idea is to create an open-access online philosophy journal (and then journals in other disciplines), with the peer review process crowd sourced. As many reviewers as want to read a paper can vote to accept/reject, with brief comments. Accepted papers will immediately be published online.
From what I can see, the open access will be free for authors. They are now recruiting reviewers.
1.審查人的名字列在審查意見書上
2.如果稿件出版，審查意見書可以隨著文稿的最終版在線上可以查閱
Open peer review" means that, firstly, the reviewers' names are included on the peer review reports, and secondly that, if the manuscript is published, the reports are made available online along with the final version of the manuscript. The published article will provide a link to its 'pre-publication history', which lists all the versions of the manuscript, all the signed reviews, and all responses to the reviewers since the submission of the manuscript until its publication.
參考資料來源http://www.biomedcentral.com/authors/authorfaq/medical
crowd-sourced peer review
The idea is to create an open-access online philosophy journal (and then journals in other disciplines), with the peer review process crowd sourced. As many reviewers as want to read a paper can vote to accept/reject, with brief comments. Accepted papers will immediately be published online.
From what I can see, the open access will be free for authors. They are now recruiting reviewers.
參考資料來源
http://philosophysmoker.blogspot.tw/2011/05/crowd-sourcing-peer-review-free-open.html
留言
張貼留言